Home Page

 Examples of engineering design challenges in literature

 

 

 

 

Have a question or comment?

 

Engineering profession

Engineering design
Skillful thinking
Process flow
Education links
Science page
Math standard(pdf)
Documents
 

 

Literacy can be expanded by creating reports, journals, presentations and modification to the story by the student. Both students and teachers see the connection between all subjects when doing an engineering design project.

The projects are done as an
inquiry based process
, with the team experience being an additional learning benefit.

 

Web Sites:

Read/Write/Think
 
 
 
 

 

 

Just within the first 39 pages of the book, Charlotte’s Web there are many challenges the students can find.

The children can select one of the challenges and then brain storm looking for ideas to solve the challenge.

 

   
Here we have a few ideas and their relationship to the state science framework .  Depending on what we want to learn, we can create the requirement so that it favors one of the strands of the framework.
Shows the process of reading a book to building a solution to the design challenges found.

Also shows that you can create other learning opportunities for the students.  As an example the students can learn about the "needs assessment strategy" you would take to find the design challenge, understand the values of the character and what constraints should be imposed.

 

 

  Process

 


 
Define strategy
Pick an additional science strand to connect;
  • earth and space
  • life science
  • physics and chemistry
Look at "story map" for ideas
Develop design challenges
Integrate the engineering design and the science strand for the grade level
Inquire-based project teams
 
Reports and rubrics

We begin to enhance the learning process by using the engineering design methodology as a connector between literature, science & mathematics. Within this process is an infusion of thinking skill strategies, such as creative and critical thinking, questions and meta-cognitive reflection. The concept uses the existing comfort level of the elementary teachers and the student’s natural engineering abilities.

 

The process begins with literature, such as fairy tales, starting in the lower grades and leading to more sophisticated stories at older ages – stories that engage students. The underlining skills of the engineering design process are related to the science process, mathematical problem solving (process) and thinking skills. Thus the student is taught how to think skillfully.

"Engineering design challenges" are created by actionable items in the story and lead to inquiry based team projects that have a design theme. As an example, in the story "Island of the Blue Dolphins", the village leaves canoes on the side of a hill for escaping a potential attack. The heroine in the story has a difficult time getting one of them down the hill and into the water. A "design challenge" for the students could be to design a system to make it easier for her to lower the canoe.
 

Picking literature:

use books to also cover the social studies themes as defined in the framework.
When choosing your book, you can integrate Social Studies/History by picking books with themes that track the Social Studies/History Framework
Pre-Kindergarten–Kindergarten: Living, Learning, and Working Together
Grade 1 : True Stories and Folk Tales from America and from Around the World 
Grade2:   E Pluribus Unum: From Many ,One 
Grade 3 : Massachusetts and its Cities and Towns: Geography and History 
Grade 4 : North American Geography with Optional Standards for One Early Civilization
Grade 5 : United States History, Geography, Economics, and Government: Early Exploration to Westward Movement
Preparation:

Pedagogy skills will allow you to engage the students by; Modeling, Scaffolding, Coaching, Reflecting and Fading.

This lesson plan will give you, the teacher, a great opportunity to work with your students to become self learners.  The process will allow you and your students to connect at least three or four subject together so you’re teaching across the curriculum and your students will see the relevance of what they are learning.

   They will not be learning in a silo but you will be working with the students in a constructionist approach.   The concepts used are based on Vygotski’s  and Piagets’ approach to early education.

Pre-existing skills needed by the students;

·        Understand the design process and what engineers do.

·        What science are we going to learn or have we just finished.

·        How to work as a team (peer interaction).

·        Students tutoring other students. 

 Starts with viewing through the “Engineering Lens”

The students and teachers should focus on thinking like an engineer when reading the literature.  Questions of the story line, author and characters around the design of a product or process for society should be the instrument to begin.  We should invite them to ask creative questions, make diverse observations, explore multiple viewpoints, reflect on their thinking process and seek personal connections of the literature.  Examples:  Why is this a special moment for the character in the story? How can we as engineers, created something for the characters in the story that will make their actions better?

Approach:

A teacher normal engages the students with the literature they are reading by asking skillful questions and using meta-cognitive reflection to bring out interesting areas of the story line.  What we are adding is an engineering lens on the process to focus those questions from an engineering designer’s viewpoint.

Define an approach for what you want the leaning outcome to be.

·        Do we want to emphasize the learning of the engineering design process?

·        Do we want to focus on a science strand within a design process?

·        Do we want to focus on teaching a thinking skill? Ie creative process

Pick a science strand to connect with, either one that you just studied (used for reinforcement) or one that you are going to study ( great Segue).

With an engineer’s perspective, use the normal teacher’s skills to engage students in the story.   …  Look at "story map" for ideas, think of engineering key words ( create, improve, identify, investigate, etc. ).  Think of the science you just studied.

Develop design challenges with the students.  Have a few in mind to channel the students towards these.

Integrate the engineering design and the science.  If you picked the science you just studied, you can ask the students to sort their design challenges around that science.  If you are going to focus on the up-coming science lesson, guide your students to view the design challenges around that science.   This will give you the teacher, a good segue into the new science lesson.

Use the 8 step design process or modified PreK-2 grade version.  Remember that the design process is cyclical in nature and having additional knowledge allows you to make better decisions.

  

Teacher Strategies

Engage the students in the story by using questions that the students identify with some design challenges. 

Look for conflicts, changes in the story line and places where a new item could help one of the characters.

·        How can someone’s quality of life be improved?, How can we make a certain task easier?, How can we improve upon an existing product?

·         Focus on key words that relate to science and engineering such as, habitat, weather, materials & tools, devices to help society, survival, plant material, and the environment.

·        Challenge the author’s assumptions in the story line by looking with the engineering view. 

·        Have students brainstorm and decide on challenge they will work on.

·        If the author was an engineer, what would be added to the story?  How can the students enhance this?

 

PreK-2 Design challenges

Story Design challenges Comments/Science
De Suess, Green Eggs & Ham Design a process to create a green egg Why are egg yokes yellow?  Are they all yellow?
Can you design a stronger trestle for the train Understand motion of objects.
   
Fairy Tale ... the wolf and 3 pigs Design a stronger house Materials and tools
Design a Solar house Sun as a source of heat and light
Design a fence around the pigs house Living things and their environment
     
Goldilocks & the three bears Security system to prevent Goldilocks from entering the house  
Design a stronger chair Investigate materials
Design an escape route for Goldilocks from the upstairs bedroom Simple forces & investigate playgrounds
Design a room in the house for the bears to hibernate Life science, animals
     
Owl Moon  by Jane Yolen
 
 
And the moon was so bright… What makes the moon bright?  Could we design something to predict the moon brightness?  Is it bright all the time? earth and space, earth part of the solar system

Develop an instrument to be sensitive to light

13. Recognize that the earth is part of a system called the “solar system” that includes the sun (a star), planets, and many moons. The earth is the third planet from the sun in our solar system.  

  Our feet crunched over the crisp snow … Could we design a shoe that would not make noise on the snow? materials, weather, kinetic molecular theory,  tools
use of materials to design a shoe that has a wide area. How do we keep the sound level?  What is sound?
7. Distinguish among the various forms of precipitation (rain, snow, sleet, and hail), making connections to the weather in a particular place and time. Grade 3-5
 

Then he called:  Whoo-whoo-who-who-who-whoooooo  …
Design an instrument that can make this sound.. What causes sound? 

Sound & light energy, Tools
4. Identify the basic forms of energy (light, sound, heat, electrical, and magnetic). Recognize that energy is the ability to cause motion or create change.
     

 

Grade3-5 Design Challenges
Story Design Challenges Comments/ science
Cricket in time square by George Sheldon Designing a home for the cricket, Adaptations of living things  
designing a sound system to amplify the crickets sound. Sound energy
Designing a food system for the cricket, mouse and cat. Energy and living things
     
On the far Side of the mountain by Jean Craighead George Design an electric generator for the water wheel. Many opportunities for designing  appliances
Design an energy efficient house  
Create a way to catch game for their food The falcon was his source of finding food
     
By the shores of Siver Lake by Laura Ingalls Wilder Build a house on the prairie  
   
design a tool to make it easier to get things on and off a wagon  
Design a song recording device for this time period  
     
Island of blue dolphins by Scott O'Neil Design a tools for digging roots  
Design a map of the island based on her verbal descriptions  
Make a skirt of Yacca fibers  
Machine to lower canoe in the water Simple machines
     
Esperanza Rising  … by Pam Munoz Ryan

 Design something to extract the juices from the rosehips (page 35 )( rosehips contain the memories of the roses and that when you drink the tea made from it, you take in the beauty that the plant had known).   

Life science , simple machines, state of matter ( solids, liquid, gases )

 Design a better habitat for the wagon that they used to escape.  

 
Living things and their environment,  tools, state of matter  

  Design a glove that you can handle a rose thorn ( page 8 )

 
Properties of Materials,  Life science ( why does it have thorns?), evolution and biodiversity,
Can we design a 1930 washing machine and Dryer that uses no electricity but only simple machines  Simple machines

Can we design a tent like structure to keep her mother cool and moist during her sickness? 

Life Science, Materials

 Esperanza and family need to take a bath.  Can we design a hot water heater without using fire?    

 

Use Solar heat and material.
     

Charotte’s Web by E.B. White

 

Well, I am pretty, replied Charlotte.  Almost all spiders are rather nice-looking.

 

“One of the pigs is a runt.  It’s very small and weak, and it will never amount to anything.  So your father has decided to do away with it”

Engr_ Identify and explain the appropriate materials and tools (e.g., hammer, screwdriver, pliers, tape measure, screws, nails, and other mechanical fasteners) to construct a given prototype safely that would provide animals more care to survive..
Life science-
design a habitat that provides a safe environment for the runt.

 

Wilbur’s new home was in the lower part of the barn, directly underneath the cows.  Mr. Zuckerman knew that a manure pile is a good place to keep a young pig.  Could design a habitat for Wilbur using paper and glue and simulate plant items from art supply store.
Earth Science:  sun and location for heat and light
Life science:  why is manure warm?  What science process is happening?

 

Templeton’s tunnel all over Zuckerman farm

Templeton the environmental engineer.   Is Templeton position in the story also an environmental engineer?  He collects all the garbage and reuses it.  Can we design our environment better to re-use our waste?

How can we use tunnels in our city?  How would we make a green tunnel?
Can do a lot of this in drawings and simple models. 
Earth science: Materials and soil
Life science:  creating an environment to live in
 
  Charlotte A. Cavatica
what does her initial A stand for? How about her last name? Can we look it up to see if there is a meaning?

She is near sited, has eight legs, and happens to be a trapper for collecting food.

What could be design for humans that would be useful using the threads of charlotte or other physical characteristics?
     

 
additional stories that will be incorporated in existing tables above
  Prepared by  Bill Wolfson.  Copyright © 2009-2010
Last Updated  0
6/05/2010